Let $T$ be a function.

Is it true that if $\exists f\forall n,m> 0.\\ \frac m {f(n)} \leq T(n,m)\leq m$

Then $\exists g.T(n,m)=\Theta(m\cdot g(n))$?

In words: is such a case, is there a function $g$ dependent only on $n$ that satisfies the above?

It looks to me true, but I am really stuck and don't know how to prove it rigorously.


No. Consider, for instance, $$T(n,m) = \begin{cases} m, & \text{$m$ even} \\ \frac{m}{n}, & \text{$m$ odd} \end{cases}$$ and notice $\frac{m}{f(n)} \le T(n, m) \le m$ holds for $f(n) = n$. Suppose $T(n,m) \in \Theta(m g(n))$ for some $g(n)$, that is, there are $c, c' > 0$ with $cmg(n) \le T(n,m) \le c'mg(n)$ for all but finitely many $m,n$. Since there are infinitely many odd $m$'s we get $g(n) \le \frac{1}{cn}$ for all but finitely many $n$. For even $m$ it then follows $$m = T(n,m) \le c' m g(n) \le \frac{c'}{c} \frac{m}{n},$$ which can only hold for finitely many $n$.

| cite | improve this answer | |
  • $\begingroup$ Thanks! What happens if I assume that $f$ is non-decreasing? $\endgroup$ – Dudi Frid Aug 23 '19 at 8:19
  • $\begingroup$ @DudiFrid I suppose you can modify $T$ so it still "jumps" between $\frac{m}{n}$ and $m$ but stretch them out enough so it's non-decreasing. The definition will be very ugly, though. $\endgroup$ – dkaeae Aug 23 '19 at 8:32

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.