Coming from a C++ background I don't understand why one needs types / type expressions as first class citizen? The only language I know that supports this feature is Aldor.

Does anybody have some literature about types as first class citizen or know some reasons why it's useful?

  • 3
    $\begingroup$ Idris has these too. $\endgroup$
    – ThreeFx
    Commented Nov 13, 2016 at 16:56
  • 1
    $\begingroup$ Are you asking about the general concept of "type is a value" (called "reflection" or "metaclasses" in various languages) or about the more specific concept of type expressions? $\endgroup$
    – svick
    Commented Nov 13, 2016 at 17:36
  • 1
    $\begingroup$ @svick I'm interested in the latter. Unfortunately I haven't found much general stuff about type expressions either so it would be nice if you could suggest some literature. $\endgroup$
    – paul98
    Commented Nov 13, 2016 at 17:49

1 Answer 1


First class types enable something called dependent typing. These allow the programmer to use values of types at type level. For example, the type of all pairs of integers is a regular type, while the pair of all integers with the left number smaller than the right number is a dependent type. The standard introductory example of this is length encoded lists (typically called Vector in Haskell/Idris). The following pseudo-code is a mixture of Idris and Haskell.

-- a natural number
data Nat = Zero | Successor Nat

data Vector length typ where
  Empty : Vector Zero typ
  (::)   : typ -> Vector length typ -> Vector (Successor length) typ

This piece of code tells us two things:

  • The empty list has length zero.
  • consing an element onto a list creates a list of length n + 1

This looks very similar to another concept with 0 and n + 1, doesn't it? I'll come back to that.

What do we gain from this? We can now determine additional properties of the functions we use. For example: An important property of append is that the length of the resulting list is the sum of the lengths of the two argument lists:

plus : Nat -> Nat -> Nat
plus          Zero n = n
plus (Successor m) n = Successor (plus m n)

append : Vector n a -> Vector m a -> Vector (plus n m) a
append Empty  ys = ys
append (x::xs) ys = x :: append xs ys

But all in all this technique does not seem all to useful in everyday programming. How does this relate to sockets, POST/GET requests and so on?

Well it doesn't (at least not without considerable effort). But it can help us in other ways:

Dependent types allow us to formulate invariants in code - rules as how a function must behave. Using these we get additional safety about the code's behaviour, similar to Eiffel's pre- and postconditions. This is extremely useful for automated theorem proving, which is one of the possible uses for Idris.

Coming back to the example above, the definition of length-encoded lists resembles the mathematical concept of induction. In Idris, you can actually formulate the concept of induction on such a list as follows:

              -- If you can supply the following:
list_induction : (Property : Vector len typ -> Type) -> -- a property to show
                  (Property Empty) -> -- the base case
                  ((w : a) -> (v : Vector n a) ->
                      Property v -> Property (w :: v)) -> -- the inductive step
                  (u : Vector m b) -> -- an arbitrary vector
                  Property u -- the property holds for all vectors

This technique is limited to constructive proofs, but is nonetheless very powerful. You can try to write append inductively as an exercise.

Of course, dependent types are just one use of first class types, but it's arguably one of the most common ones. Additional uses include, for example, returning a specific type from a function based on its arguments.

type_func : Vector n a -> Type
type_func Empty = Nat
type_func v     = Vector (Successor Zero) Nat

f : (v : Vector n a) -> type_func v
f Empty = 0
f vs    = length vs :: Empty

This is a nonsensical example, but it demonstrates something you cannot emulate without first class types.


Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service and acknowledge you have read our privacy policy.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.